Buy-to-Let is back, but are new investors ready?

• Buy-to-let applications have reached 14% nationally, signalling renewed appetite among South Africans to build wealth through residential property.
• The Western Cape is leading investor activity, with investment purchases accounting for more than 30% of recent home-loan applications.
• Strong rentals alone don't guarantee returns, investors must understand cash flow, leverage, vacancies, costs and tax before buying.

Buy-to-let is back 

South Africans are returning to investment property as rental demand strengthens, but buying the wrong property could quickly destroy returns.

South Africans are returning to residential property investment in numbers not seen for years, encouraged by stronger rental markets, improved sentiment and renewed confidence in property as a wealth-building asset.

Recent ooba Home Loans data showed buy-to-let buyers accounting for a record 14% of mortgage applications nationally in January, while more than 30% of applications in the Western Cape were for investment properties. Separate Standard Bank data has similarly put the Western Cape figure at around 31%.

The attraction is understandable. Rental growth has been running strongly, vacancies remain relatively tight across many markets, and residential property offers investors something few other mainstream asset classes do: the ability to use long-term debt to acquire an income-producing asset.

But a stronger market can also draw inexperienced investors into deals without properly interrogating the numbers.

Renier Kriek, Managing Director of alternative housing financier Sentinel Homes, warns that investors should distinguish between buying good real estate and making a good investment.

‍

“When investor demand runs strongly, the danger is that people begin asking what they should buy before asking what the investment has to achieve,” says Kriek. “A property can be perfectly good real estate and still be a poor investment at the price you are paying.”

‍

For first-time investors, the objective shouldn't be to accumulate properties as quickly as possible. It should be to acquire an asset that fits a clearly defined strategy, learn how to operate it effectively and build the financial capacity to make the next investment.

‍

“This way, you can develop the knowledge, capabilities, and savvy to achieve your financial goals, while learning to reduce the risk of overextending yourself,” says Kriek.

‍

First steps: Learn before you leverage

‍Your first investment property is effectively a training ground. Two of the most important disciplines to master are finance and investment strategy.

Leverage can be one of property's greatest advantages. Borrowing allows investors to control an asset worth considerably more than their initial equity contribution and potentially magnify their return on that equity. But leverage works in both directions.

Excessive debt can turn an otherwise sound investment into a financial burden when interest rates rise, vacancies occur or unexpected expenses hit.

Investors therefore need to understand concepts such as return on equity, capitalisation rates, net operating income and cash-on-cash returns rather than simply looking at the monthly rental against the bond repayment.

Strategy matters just as much. Traditional buy-to-let, short-term rentals, student accommodation, rent-to-rent and commercial property each have different income profiles, operating requirements and risks.

An investment model that worked exceptionally well over the past decade isn't automatically the right strategy for the next decade.

Short-term rentals, for example, can offer attractive gross revenues in the right locations but bring additional operational, seasonal and regulatory risks. Student accommodation can deliver strong demand but requires a clear understanding of location, operating costs, funding and the needs of the student market.

Buying multiple properties before understanding these dynamics can simply multiply the consequences of a poor strategy. “Patiently nurturing your first property towards profitability results in confidence to invest wisely and securely in the future,” says Kriek.

Self-supporting growth: Can the property carry itself?

‍Capital growth is important, but beginner investors often make the mistake of buying primarily for what they believe a property could be worth five or ten years from now.

The more immediate question is: How much of its own cost can the property support through rental income?

A good investment doesn't necessarily need to be cash-flow positive from the day of transfer. But any monthly shortfall needs to be understood and budgeted for before the purchase.

‍

“A property does not have to be cash-flow positive from day one to be a good investment. But, if you have to cover a R4,000 income shortfall per month, that contribution must be part of the investment thesis, not an unpleasant discovery after transfer,” says Kriek.

‍

“Ideally, you should be prepared to cover more than just the shortfall, because there will be maintenance, vacancy, or tenant non-payment at some point in the future.”

‍

Investors should establish the achievable rental, not the rental needed to make their spreadsheet work. Research comparable rentals in the suburb and, where relevant, within the same sectional-title scheme. Then deduct realistic operating expenses to determine the property's net operating income (NOI).

If the income is too low relative to the capital required, investors shouldn't be afraid to walk away.

The objective isn't necessarily to find the cheapest property. It's to find one capable of producing sustainable returns and moving towards being self-supporting within a reasonable period, ideally from day one, but potentially within the first few years.

Know the numbers: Rent minus bond is not profit

‍One of the most dangerous equations in property investment is:
Rental income – bond instalment = profit. It doesn't.

The true cost of owning an investment property extends considerably beyond the mortgage. Before buying, investors should model at least the following:

• Bond repayments: Allow for interest costs and the possibility of future rate movements.
• Rates and taxes: Municipal charges form part of the property's recurring operating cost and generally increase over time.
• Levies: Sectional-title and HOA properties carry levies that can materially affect net returns. Special levies are an additional risk.
• Maintenance: Setting aside around 5% - 10% of rental income can provide a useful buffer for repairs and ongoing maintenance.
• Vacancies: Don't model 12 months' rent as guaranteed income. A conservative forecast should allow for periods without a tenant.
• Realistic rental income: Use achievable market rentals based on comparable properties rather than optimistic assumptions.
• Income tax: Net rental income may form part of taxable income, while the capital portion of a mortgage repayment is generally not deductible.
• Capital gains tax: A future sale can create a CGT liability that needs to be considered when assessing the investment's ultimate return.
• Tax deductions: Qualifying expenses incurred in producing rental income may generally be deductible, while capital improvements receive different tax treatment.
• Investment incentives: Qualifying residential investments may potentially benefit from specific provisions such as Section 13sex of the Income Tax Act, subject to meeting the applicable requirements.

The important principle is to stress-test the investment.

• What happens if the property is vacant for two months? What if a tenant defaults? What if an unexpected R30,000 repair arises? What happens if rates, levies or insurance rise faster than rent?
• “You have to manage a property investment like a business, considering not just income and expenses, but also cash flow disruptions that create unwanted pressure on your finances,” says Kriek.
• “And remember that risk management is central to running any business.”

Funding your portfolio: Let the first property earn the next

‍Building a property portfolio sustainably is less about buying quickly and more about creating sufficient financial strength to keep buying.

A well-selected first property with strong rental potential can begin producing surplus cash as rentals increase, debt reduces and operating efficiencies improve. Those profits can be reinvested into the property, used to reduce debt or accumulated towards the equity required for another acquisition.

As the outstanding bond reduces, investors can also build equity in the asset, potentially strengthening their financial position when applying for future funding.

But the next purchase should not simply happen because equity is available.

‍

“It’s a disciplined approach that helps you develop a sense of timing, which is essential to building a strong and sustainable property portfolio,” says Kriek.

‍

The goal should be for every acquisition to strengthen the portfolio rather than simply make it bigger.

The investor lesson

‍The return of buy-to-let investors is a positive signal for South Africa's residential market. Strong rental demand and improving investor confidence are creating opportunities, particularly where properties can generate sustainable income.

But a rising market doesn't remove investment risk. The first question shouldn't be “What property should I buy?” It should be: “What return must this investment produce, what could go wrong and can I afford it when it does?”

Successful property investing is ultimately not measured by the number of properties an investor owns, but by the quality of the income, equity and sustainable returns those properties produce.

Start with one good investment. Understand every number. Manage it like a business. Then let that experience and the asset itself, help fund the next one.

‍