Municipal Crackdown: Penalty rates hit illegal property use

• Cash-strapped municipalities are aggressively enforcing zoning laws to recover revenue through penalty rates.
• Everyday property uses like Airbnb, student letting and home businesses now trigger inspections and fines.
• Non-compliant owners face back-dated charges, legal action and sharply higher monthly municipal bills.

Municipalities turn enforcement into revenue recovery

South African property owners are facing a new, far tougher reality. As municipal finances come under growing strain, illegal land-use enforcement has shifted from a compliance function to a revenue-recovery strategy.

Across metros and secondary cities alike, inspection teams are intensifying audits, issuing compliance notices, and imposing steep penalty rates on properties used outside their approved zoning.

The result: homeowners, landlords and investors are increasingly being hit with unexpected, sometimes back-dated, municipal charges that can run into tens or even hundreds of thousands of rand.

According to VDM Incorporated Director Cor van Deventer, this is no longer an isolated phenomenon. It is a coordinated national trend driven by both legal authority and fiscal desperation.

‍

“Municipalities are under enormous financial pressure, and they are now actively using penalty rates as a revenue stabilisation tool. The enforcement we’re seeing today is far more aggressive than in the past, and many owners have no idea their current property use is unlawful until the penalty arrives,” says Van Deventer.

‍

Legal Backing: Why municipal power has sharply increased

The turning point was the 2021 Supreme Court of Appeal ruling in City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Zibi, which confirmed that municipalities may impose penalty rates for unlawful land use without first amending the valuation roll.

‍

“This judgment fundamentally strengthened municipal enforcement powers,” Van Deventer explains. “It allows them to penalise unauthorised use immediately, and in some cases retrospectively. That’s why we’re now seeing back-dated charges and penalty tariffs several times higher than standard residential rates.”

‍

How Municipalities Conduct Inspections, what they look for

Municipal enforcement is now structured, data-driven and systematic. Most follow a four-stage process:

1. Desktop audits & data matching
Zoning records, approved building plans, utility consumption, neighbour complaints, online listings (Airbnb, student housing portals) and valuation data are cross-checked. Discrepancies trigger red flags.

2. Physical site inspections
Inspectors look for:

• Multiple entrances, mailboxes or doorbells
• Subdivided units or backyard dwellings
• Business signage or high visitor traffic
• Evidence of short-term or student letting

3. Plan & approval verification
Structures and alterations are compared with approved building plans. Any mismatch can lead to contravention notices and penalties.

4. Enforcement & penalty imposition
Municipalities may issue compliance directives, levy penalty tariffs, back-date charges, demand rezoning or consent use applications, and pursue legal action for ongoing non-compliance.

‍

“This is no longer complaint-driven policing. It is proactive, systematic enforcement,” Van Deventer warns.

‍

A growing enforcement trend across provinces

Recent actions confirm this is nationwide:

• Tshwane: Over 700 properties issued penalty rates in a single compliance drive.
• Johannesburg: Intensified inspections of student accommodation, Airbnb units and home-based businesses.
• Cape Town: Crackdown on unauthorised second dwellings, short-term letting and backyard rentals.
• eThekwini: Linking illegal land-use enforcement directly to revenue protection strategies.

Smaller municipalities are following suit, often quietly, meaning owners only discover contraventions when their accounts spike.

Common property uses now triggering penalty rates

‍Penalty tariffs are increasingly applied to:

• Short-term letting (Airbnb) in non-approved zones
• Student accommodation in single-residential areas
• Home-based businesses without consent use
• Backyard rentals or additional dwellings without approval
• Unapproved structural alterations
• Crèches, salons, workshops or consulting rooms from homes
• Multi-tenant use in single-residential zoning

‍

“Even well-intentioned owners are being caught,” says Van Deventer. “What feels like normal income-generating use may be illegal in zoning terms and municipalities are no longer turning a blind eye.”

‍

What Homeowners and Investors should do now

Van Deventer urges proactive risk management:

1. Confirm your zoning rights
2. Verify your actual use matches zoning permissions
3. Apply for rezoning or consent use where required
4. Regularise building plans and structures
5. Respond immediately to municipal notices
6. Seek legal advice before penalties escalate

Final Word

With municipal finances under severe strain, zoning enforcement has become a powerful fiscal weapon. The days of informal, tolerated property use are over. For investors and homeowners, compliance is no longer optional, it is now a core component of asset protection.

‍

As Van Deventer concludes: “Enforcement will only intensify. The smartest move is to fix compliance now, before penalty rates and legal action fix your cash flow for you.”

‍